Glenda Pencer and the Wish Dish
Glenda Pencer bets her husband that she could cook the tastiest chicken dish. She enlists the help of a mysterious and devilish stranger. The stranger appers to know more than he should and Glenda Pencer can stand it no longer. So she grabs an axe.
This story was published before 2007 into the Twisted Tongue anthology. I used the pen name P.Grey.
Here is a link to the listing.
Here is another link to another listing.